COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF GOOGLE TRANSLATE AND DEEPL IN ENGLISH–UZBEK LITERARY TRANSLATION
Main Article Content
Abstract
This article presents a comparative analysis of two leading neural machine translation systems — Google Translate and DeepL — applied to English–Uzbek literary translation. A corpus of literary texts (short stories and novel excerpts, ~5,000 words) was translated with both systems, and the outputs were analysed using the five-group error typology. Results show that the systems exhibit different error profiles: Google Translate tends toward generalisation and omission, while DeepL tends toward preservation of source structures and transliteration. For literary translation, neither system reaches publishable quality; both require full post-editing, with DeepL output generally requiring somewhat less effort for morphological correction. The article analyses strengths and weaknesses of each system by error group, proposes a usage strategy (system selection and combination based on text characteristics), and discusses implications for post-editing workflow design. The conclusion argues that system comparison should be based on post-editing effort rather than raw output quality, and that for Uzbek, the choice between systems matters less than the post-editor's competence.
Article Details
Section
References
1.Koponen M. Is machine translation post-editing worth the effort? A survey of research into post-editing and effort // The Journal of Specialised Translation. 2016. № 25. P. 131–148.
2.Toral A., Wieling M., Way A. Post-editing effort of a novel with statistical and neural machine translation // Frontiers in Digital Humanities. 2018. Vol. 5. Art. 9.
3.Moorkens J., Toral A., Castilho S., Way A. Translators' perceptions of literary post-editing using statistical and neural machine translation // Translation Spaces. 2018. Vol. 7, № 2. P. 240–262.
4.Богданова К. В. Постредактирование машинного перевода как студенческий проект (на материале художественного текста) // Исследования языка и современное гуманитарное знание. 2024. Т. 6, № 3. С. 172–183.
5.Vieira L. N. Post-editing of machine translation // The Routledge Handbook of Translation and Technology / ed. by M. O'Hagan. London: Routledge, 2019. P. 319–335.
6.Hamroyeva Sh., Matyakubova N. Mashina tarjimasida matnni moslashtirish usullari // Uzbekistan: Til va madaniyat. 2023. № 2. B. 6–19.
7.Yendirboyeva Z. Z. Mashina tarjimasi: til va texnologiya kesishmasidagi dolzarb masalalar // American Journal of Social Science. 2025. Vol. 3, № 9.